MIND-BLOWING! Millions of fans waited patiently, but in the end, John Dutton and his family never resolved the ranch’s “curse.” Instead, Taylor Sheridan stands accused of “lazy writing,” abandoning countless storylines and EVEN KILLING THE MEANING of 1883 — arguably the best prequel! This is the “haunting” ending that leaves fans absolutely enraged!

You thought the behind-the-scenes battle between Taylor Sheridan and Kevin Costner was Yellowstone‘s biggest scar? That was just the tip of the iceberg! The MONUMENTAL and most destructive mistake by this celebrated creator lies at the very core of the story, in his BETRAYAL of a promise sown in the best prequel – 1883 – making Yellowstone‘s ending a horrifying disappointment that has alienated millions of fans!

While all attention was fixated on the Kevin Costner drama and John Dutton’s fate, what truly “killed” Yellowstone was Taylor Sheridan’s complete loss of narrative direction, abandoning numerous plot threads and forgetting an iconic prophecy from the very universe he meticulously built.

1. THE FATEFUL DECEPTION: The “Seven Generations” Prophecy Forgotten – How Taylor Sheridan Ruined 1883!

In the critically acclaimed prequel 1883, an iconic scene planted a chilling and deeply significant prophecy in viewers’ minds. Spotted Eagle, a Native American chief, told James Dutton (John Dutton’s great-grandfather, played by Tim McGraw) that the Yellowstone Ranch would return to Native American hands after seven generations of Duttons had lived there. This wasn’t just a minor detail; this was the spiritual core of the entire franchise, a predetermined fate that fans had awaited for so long!

Yet, what happened in Yellowstone‘s ending? Instead of witnessing the seventh generation of Duttons (specifically Tate Dutton, Kayce’s son) confronting this prophecy, Kayce Dutton simply gave up the ranch! This not only contradicted the prophecy but was also seen as an act of lazy and careless writing by Taylor Sheridan. Fans have pointed out that, in proper generational order: James Dutton -> Spencer Dutton -> John Dutton Jr. -> John Dutton III (Kevin Costner) -> Kayce Dutton -> Tate Dutton (the seventh generation). The fact that Kayce, who belongs to only the fifth generation, made the decision to “give up” rendered the prophecy meaningless and betrayed, shattering the expectations of millions who had followed from the very beginning!

2. THE DEADLY MESSAGE: Kevin Costner Drama Was Just The Last Straw, Yellowstone’s CORE PROBLEM Has Been Exposed!

While media and fans focused their attention on the Taylor Sheridan and Kevin Costner drama – leading to Costner’s departure and John Dutton’s character being treated “disrespectfully” – this article asserts: The Costner drama was merely a symptom, not the disease! It simply exposed long-simmering issues within Yellowstone.

Even before Costner’s exit, Taylor Sheridan was criticized for abandoning too many storylines and sometimes developing female characters in a “one-dimensional” way. But Costner’s departure was like a final “punch,” bringing every flaw of Yellowstone to the surface. The storyline became disjointed, the ending was rushed and felt forced, unnatural. Even the “easy” decision to hand over the Yellowstone Ranch after decades of bloodshed and power struggles by the Duttons, is seen as a “fool’s dream” of giving up power.

3. THE STOLEN ENDING: Yellowstone Failed To Live Up To Its GRAND Potential!

Yellowstone, with its strong start and promising premise, had the potential to be a truly great series. However, according to many fans, it failed to reach that peak. Taylor Sheridan’s inability (or unwillingness) to resolve the most crucial prophecies, his failure to maintain narrative consistency, and allowing behind-the-scenes controversies to impact production quality, resulted in an unflattering and controversial ending.

This disappointment isn’t limited to Yellowstone but also extends to how 1883 is viewed, as a deep and historically significant storyline was “irresponsibly” abandoned in the parent series. Was Taylor Sheridan too ambitious in expanding the Yellowstone universe without being able to tightly manage the main plot? Or is this simply the price of immense success?

Do you agree that Taylor Sheridan’s biggest mistake in Yellowstone was forgetting the “seven generations” prophecy? Did this ending make you feel “betrayed”? Share your SHOCKING opinions immediately below!